So, watching these films in chronological order really separates them apart. This film for example, really focuses on the 'cool' aspect of the Force. The Jedis are so superior in combat to everyone else it's just ridiculous. It's as if people watching this film have forgotten what Luke and Obiwan were like in the original series. Sure, they could lay the smack down when they needed to, but were still fairly vulnerable. In this film, everyone is just so overpowered it doesn't even make sense. Literally every blast is not only deflected by a lightsaber, but deflected right back at who shot it. The original trilogy is not like that. But anyways, This is a fairly enjoyable film. Some bad acting on the part of certain child actors, and some poorly written dialogue that seems forced, but all in all it's pretty good. The podracing scene really stands out, it's just so fun. One thing that bothered me was the lack of consequence to violence. There is only one instance where blood is actually drawn, and it's just a slight hint of a red mist. It just seems toned down intentionally so they could open this to a broader market of youth.
7.5/10
Film#37 - Attack of the Clones, 2002, dir. George Lucas
The problem with this film is many of the action sequences are just plain boring. When Obiwan and Anakin are chasing down Padme's would be assassin, it's just a drawn out chase sequence where very little actually happens. It's action for the sake of action. Hayden Christensen and Natalie Portman have literally no chemistry and their entire relationship seems unnatural. not to mention he is fairly unbelievable as a character in the first place. The entire thing seems awkward and uncomfortable.
6.5/10
Film#38 - Revenge of the Sith, 2005, dir. George Lucas
This film really just blends with the last one. It's much more about bridging the parts of the story than it is actually telling it's own story. Anakin switches to the dark side a little too easily, and along with several poorly acted scenes makes this film almost unbearable. But I say almost, because after all it is part of a series that defines a genre, however this particular film is fairly ineffective on it's own. It would be just as good as episode 2, except scenes like Darth Vader's infamous "NOOOOO" scene just takes it down another notch.
6/10
Film#39 - A New Hope, 1977, dir. George Lucas
So going back to this film after so long, it really does still hold true even today. The special effects (minus the updated George Lucas abominations, which I had to endure since I couldn't get my hands on the original films) are clearly faulty by todays standards but are in a way more respectable. Whenever a lightsaber goes on, you can see a cut in the film, which I would assume would be where the actors would freeze while someone ran in and attached a rod to the lightsaber to later add the glow effect on, which in some ways is a little jarring but still very innovative for the time. It's a good film, I just can't say it's amazing. Much of the dialogue is weak and relies on the style and 'cool' aspect to carry it at times, but still very good.
8/10
Film#40 - The Empire Strikes Back, 1980, dir. Irvin Kershner
This is my favourite Star Wars film. Despite what people may think ,these films are fairly different. This one combines what I think is more effective acting (maybe the 3 years between films gave the actors the chance to really develop their characters) with more natural and often witty dialogue (Han is truly hilarious) and a more diverse range of beautiful scenery, making the most effective of the film series. At this point in the series, the whole idea of the Force and the galaxy it takes place in has been established, allowing the film to focus on the narrative and character development. We see a real depth to Han and Luke in particular, with more exposing narrative structure.
9/10
Film#41 - Return of the Jedi, 1983, dir. Richard Marquand
Not too much actually happens in this film. There are basically only two large scenes: rescuing Han, and the attack on the new Death Star. There is a real lack of plot points compared to the previous films, which take place over multiple planets and solar systems, with all sorts of changes in scenery. Despite this change of pace, the film is still pretty good. The developments with Luke and Vader are interesting but somehow out of character and forced at times. Leia and Han have almost lost the chemistry they had in the previous film, even though this film tries to make it seem as if their bond is stronger. The film starts out incredibly cinematic, something that is still such high quality today, but seems to deteriorate as it moves on, giving up on creative and stunning camera angles and scenery (I would discuss mise-en-scene but that's too pretentious) in favour of just presenting the story (camera angles for the sake of showing the action rather than constructing something artistic). An interesting end to the series.
7.5/10